You miss mid-budget thrillers with stars taking weird swings. You enjoy films that ask “Who’s using whom?”—and answer it three different ways. Or you just want to see Hugh Jackman eat a steak while lying through his perfect teeth.

When Deception hit theaters in 2008, it arrived with a slick poster, a moody blue-and-black palette, and a cast that promised high-stakes intrigue: Hugh Jackman, Ewan McGregor, and Michelle Williams. Directed by Marcel Langenegger (in his only feature film), the movie dove headfirst into Manhattan’s shadowy underground of secret sex clubs, corporate fraud, and identity theft.

Have you seen it? Did the twist get you, or did you see it coming a block away? Let’s discuss below. 👇